I note that this relay does add a small control delay. You've actually got normal RC control delay plus normal OpLink control delay. This is not enough to generally cause problems, but can make close in FPV hovering even more challenging.
What are the typical values of the oplink control delay? 20-30ms?
Radiolink claims their AT9S system has fast response, 3ms only, while all channels act synchronously. This delay is almost non-existant, at least for my far-from-perfect pilot skills
So it is only the oplink induced delay that matters when using the relay. I cannot feel it at all when flying planes. For quads - there is maybe, only maybe, a minimal added "softness" in controls compared to direct 2.4GHz radio-control, but I cannot swear I really feel it as I don't usually fly my long-range copters race-style
...
With your idea, how long has it been, a couple years ago? I "built" a simpler setup onto an arrow. Simple but functional. Arrow point sticks in the ground and the antenna is on top. RC transmitter to OpLink relay with bluetooth.
The Oplink has an RFM23BP and an added power input (fed from external 5V/6V) and filtering for it. The added power input feeds the RF directly and also connects to the OpLink mainport/flexiport and thus provides power for everything. There is also a silicon diode from normal +5V OpLink power input (usb/mainport/flexiport) to the RF so that it will still work at approximately stock RF power if the second power input is disconnected. I often power it via USB from my laptop/GCS and skip the battery. BEC has a jumper for 5V/6V so I can actually run it at 6V, but I have never tried that and probably never will. So RF has 3 different possible power inputs, 4.3V, 5V, and 6V.
...
I've initally made a similar setup like yours, on a pole, with the idea to position the OPLINK TX antenna as high as possible for a better range. However, I had concerns about moisture protection of electronics and higher chance of mechanical damage during transportation. Also found it not very convenient to carry with me. So I've put it all in a small box, later decided to use an OLED display for GPS coordinates from telemetry and finally added SD card logging functionality to avoid taking a laptop with me every time. Relay box logger also proved more reliable than smartphone or laptop logging. GCS or smartphone(running LP2Go) occasionally happen to hang/stop while recording on long flights and no log at all...
Now I easily fit all the necessary control and FPV equipment and the 250size quad in the bottom of my tourists backpack (80+15l) when going to interesting locations away from roads
Some time ago I've played with RFM23BPS and managed to boost its power output to 3.5-3.8W (RF MOSFET powered with approx 10V - that is why second switching buck/boost regulator is added in the relay box - on the photo). No overheating, I've tested it for 8 hours connected to Revo receiver.
However, good antenna with low SWR is required. Otherwise the module shuts down or may even burn as it has no protection on output. I'm using the relay box with the excellent
Retevis RHD-771 SMA-M that you commented here:
https://forum.librepilot.org/index.php?topic=4199.0Anyway, 3.5W is way more than needed and sane to use normally. I have made this power option in the relay box switchable via key on the RC transmitter to be used in emergency occasions only. Aside initial tests I've used it only once for 10-15 seconds.
As a side effect of RFM23BPS mods, the "standard" 1W output @6V was raised to approx 1.3W.
On USB power only, I've measured the output approx. 600mW.
I don't think I'll go for 1W Revo mod, although I had such ideas some time ago. I'm afraid the reworked Revo won't be robust and reliable enough. And I've found that standard Revo 100mW TX power is enough to maintain telemetry downlink up to distances of 15km with plain omnidirectional antennas on both sides.
Here are some snapshots from the telemetry log replay of a recent flight. Total travelled distance: 42km, max. distance from start location: 15.2km. No breaks in control or in the
[email protected].
I've noticed, and it comforms the theory, that link quality is significantly better when the relay box antenna is far from ground (or any ground plane like the steel roof of a car). Placing the relay box on a tripod works very well.
I guess a Moxon or a small Yagi at the ground station (the relay box) will be sufficient to go to 22-25km with telemetry @57.6kbps.
The telemetry is important, because I use GPS data to feed it to the video antenna tracker station.
The tracker station is DIY, based on the GhettoStation project:
https://github.com/KipK/Ghettostation/wiki I had revised the code to be compatible with latest Librepilot releases (currently up to next 735). Also did some critical bugfixes and added new features/enhancements. Plan to upload the code to Github to share with the Librepilot community in the near future.
--------------------------------
Off-topic:
...
I am currently limited by FPV video range, but I am considering an RFM23BP Revo mod and using OpMap or the synthesized FPV of OSGEarth for ground based projects, etc.
...
I've recently managed to improve the the FPV video range (1280MHz) I get with my equippment by carefully adjusting video level in the VTX (800mW Partom from Banggood, real output is 560-600mW). The preset video level was lower than standard 1V, it was closer to 0.85V. I was surprised how clearer and more stable the video became at distaces over 7-8km after I'd fine-tuned the video level (with the pot in the VTX) to 1V.
I'm using TrueRC Singularity for TX antenna. These are amaizingly well manifactured and tuned! I've tested the two of them I have with a sweep antenna analyser and got their center frequencies measured at 1279.8MHz & 1283MHz !
The receiver is ReadyMadeRC w/Comtech tuner (narrow SAW filter) VRX with additional SPF5189 LNA, very well shielded and with cleanest possible power supply I could build for it.
Receiving antenna is DIY IBCrazy's CrossHair. I've built it following his instruction in the tutorial and the dedicated thread:
https://fpvlab.com/forums/showthread.php?3626-Crosshair-10-dbic-Circularly-polarized-antenna-tutorial!Of course, IBCrazy (VideoAerialSystems) also makes and sells new and improved designs of the CrossHair and PepperBox:
https://www.videoaerialsystems.com/products/crosshair-xtreme?variant=29827111518311https://www.videoaerialsystems.com/collections/antennas/products/pepperbox-xtreme?variant=29827341811815At the most recent tests I've got quite clean video @15km, despite the RF interference in the area. Now the real range limiting factor becomes the battery capacity
Sadly, youtube compression badly spoiled the original DVR record quality. Anyway, looks little better if settings / quality manually raised to 1080p or if watched fullscreen in youtube...
----------------------
The antenna analyser I've mentioned is quite cheap but can be really useful when building and tuning DIY 433MHz and 1.2GHz antennas.
I've bought it recently from Banggood:
https://www.banggood.com/Geekcreit-Spectrum-Analyzer-USB-LTDZ_35-4400M_Spectrum-Signal-Source-with-Tracking-Source-Module-RF-Frequency-Domain-Analysis-Tool-p-1450129.html?rmmds=myorder&cur_warehouse=CNThere is also an encased variant:
https://www.banggood.com/Geekcreit-Spectrum-Analyzer-USB-LTDZ-35-4400M-Signal-Source-with-Tracking-Source-Module-RF-Frequency-Domain-Analysis-Tool-With-Aluminum-Shell-p-1494125.html?rmmds=detail-left-hotproducts__1&cur_warehouse=CNFew other components needed:
1. A return loss / reflection bridge like this one:
https://www.banggood.com/RF-SWR-Bridge-0_1-3000MHz-Return-Loss-Bridge-Reflection-Bridge-Antenna-Analyzer-VHF-VSWR-Return-Loss-p-1497170.html?rmmds=search&cur_warehouse=CNHave to say this one seems badly manifactured, at least on the photo. Mine looks similar but I've ordered it an year ago from ebay and is of much better assembly quality.
2. A 50ohm terminator and a suitable length (25-40cm) RF cable (RG402) with SMA connectors.
3. Optionally, few attenuators.
Here I've found a summarized info:
https://www.rudiswiki.de/wiki9/SpectrumAnalyzer_LTDZI've always wanted to have an antenna analyser but never had convinced myself to pay hundred(s) dollars/euros to buy one.
This cheap module, although being inferior to the original NWT units and the more expensive and high quality analysers, does good enough job to test and tune my DIY antennas